Share |

Jewish Intactivists Increasingly Vocal in Israel

Kahal, an active social group for Israeli parents with intact sons, counts thousands of Israeli Jews among it's members.
Kahal, a social group for Israeli parents with intact sons is active and counts thousands of Israeli Jews among it's members.

Intactivism—the movement to end circumcision—continues to win social acceptance worldwide, including in the Jewish state of Israel. Jews in the holy land are increasingly open to questioning circumcision, much more so than in the United States. In recent years, Jewish Intactivists have published articles and essays in some of Israel’s largest papers including Haaretz (Israel’s largest and most influential daily paper), 927mag, and the Jerusalem Post. A variety of active Intactivist groups such as Gonnen (Protect the Child), The Israeli Organization Against Genital Mutilation/Intact Son, and Kahal (a community group for parents of intact sons) have sprung up. The leaders of Kahal say that thousands of Israeli Jews are choosing to keep their sons intact.

We are Israeli Jews who are proud of our heritage and religion, and who see a need to make adjustments to protect the well-being of our sons. Judaism is a religion of constant evolution and ethical advancement. Early in Judaism animal sacrifice was abandoned, and Rabbis chose to abolish capital punishment. Many Jews and Israelis recognize that it is time that circumcision shift into a symbolic ritual such as the well-popularized Brit Shalom. Over 100 Rabbis are willing to do a Bris ceremony without circumcision, and this includes some Rabbis in Israel.

Update on the Jewish Intactivist Movement in Israel

“I am a Jewish filmmaker and I have been invited by the Council of Europe to its Parliamentary Assembly next week. By screening my television documentary It’s a Boy! For European parliamentarians I aim to help shore up their commitment to protection of children’s right to physical integrity – a key step toward ending ritual circumcision of boys….From a very young age attending Jewish schools my personal preoccupation was the Jewish thirst for justice and our empathy for suffering. Tsa’ar ba’alei chayim, the Jewish injunction to heed the distress of living beings, became the wellspring of the filmmaking I’m most proud of, including films about Israeli society, its past, present and future.…Had I known such facts earlier, my son would have remained intact, as is the case with increasing numbers of Jewish boys today, including thousands in Israel… Parents like me know from our remorse that it was wrong to make such an irreversible, painful and dangerous decision for our children. We owed our children protection, and we owe it to our communities not to be silenced when we have erred as parents. …boys from all backgrounds need the protection of the rule of law – secular law – wherever they may live. The necessity for this now in Israel is obvious. To deprive children of Jewish and Muslim descent in any country of full legal protection because of their lineage amounts to a most perverse kind of prejudice against those children. As for any attempt by real anti-Semites to latch onto this issue, that would be denounced publicly. But then real anti-Semites are not usually the people keen to protect Jewish children from harm, and real anti-Semites would probably like nothing better than continuance of a practice that stokes anti-Jewish feelings and for generation after generation inflicts suffering on Jewish boys. Children’s right to physical integrity should be what Israeli parliamentarians defend – rather than a brutal anachronism.”
Victor Shoenfeld, Circumcision – defending the indefensible, Jerusalem Post, 01/22/2014.

“There is a small but growing movement of Jewish parents who reject ritual circumcision, and I think it’s going to spread fast because they’re saying out loud what so many Jewish parents are thinking: ‘Why?’ And this, I believe, is the best answer to the problem: Stand up for your kid and say no. If you fear and abhor the ritual, don’t let anyone perform it on him. He’ll still be Jewish if you raise him Jewish – whatever anyone says.”
Larry Derfner, Stand up for your son: Say ‘no’ to ritual circumcision, 972mag (Israel), June 29, 2012.


“Hard though it may be to hear, irreversibly removing a healthy body part – in this case, part of a boy’s genitals – without consent, violates a person’s right to bodily integrity, a cornerstone of post-Holocaust human rights law. It also undermines that child’s right to an open future....
Supporters of circumcision also say it’s an ancient, meaningful practice. But neither longevity nor meaning is usually accepted as sufficient moral justification to override individual rights. As one Orthodox Jewish father, Elie Jesner, puts it, “Mankind has been doing horrendous things for thousands of years: slavery, capital punishment, condemning homosexuals, oppressing women. That is not a club of actions I want to be part of.”
From a Jewish perspective, there are other issues. First, circumcision does not confer Jewish status. As Shaye Cohen, professor of Hebrew literature and philosophy at Harvard University, explains, “Male and female offspring of a Jewish mother are Jewish by birth under Jewish law; the male offspring are Jewish by birth even if they are left uncircumcised.” Second, biblical circumcision was not as extensive as today’s variant, which is actually an innovation of rabbis in the Hellenic period trying to stop Jewish men from restoring their foreskins. Evidently, definitional Jewish practices can and have evolved.
Given all of this, it’s not surprising that some Jews are questioning the practice. A 2006 online survey reported in Haaretz found that nearly a third of parents of boys would prefer to forgo circumcision, but have it done primarily for social reasons. Israel is now home to the intact support group Kahal, while in the United States, Beyond the Bris and Jews Against Circumcision have sprung up.
Jews who question circumcision from the point of view of human rights and medical ethics should be respected, not demonized. But all critics of circumcision must be vigilant about the company they keep, distancing themselves from anyone not exclusively motivated by child protection. There is no place for anti-Semitic arguments or imagery...
Meanwhile, the Council of Europe should stand firm. If it backs down and denies some children their rights because their parents adhere to the Jewish tradition, it would single out only those children for lack of protection. Now that really would be anti-Semitic.
Dr. Rebecca Steinfeld, It cuts both ways: A Jew argues for child rights over religious circumcision, Haaretz (Israel), Nov. 26, 2013.

“Israeli circumcision critic Eran Sadeh (featured in the above news broadcast) has been working hard to educate Jewish people in Israel about the downsides to foreskin removal. He is the founder of the Israeli group Gonnen Al Hayeled (Protect the Child) and he is also a Beyond the Bris contributing writer. There can be no doubt that Sadeh’s advocacy is playing a large role in getting Israeli parents to think critically about this once universally accepted tradition.”
Circumcision In Israel Not Taken For Granted Anymore,

”After my exposure to the information regarding circumcision, I refuse to mutilate my baby. I don’t have the right and I do not agree! He was born whole and he will stay whole! His integrity is his full right! The Religious Court has no right to do that! No one in the whole world is authorized to force me to mutilate my son, to cut his penis!... In particular, religious oppression, unnecessary cutting of the penis of a helpless baby? A non-reversible surgical operation! A foreskin does not renew itself!
The baby can not express his own will. The right to decide is his alone. It is his body! The right, is not mine, nor anyone else’s in the entire world, but his own only!”
Elinor, Israeli Mom, Jewish Mom Makes Intactivist Case in Israel.

“When my beloved son was born I didn’t circumcise him. It was an easy and natural step, which I saw as an expression of my existence as a free man.
I’m opposed to circumcision, and also have reservations about the use of the term ‘brit milah’ (‘covenant of circumcision’). It involves cutting the infant’s sexual organ, and I am opposed to the cutting of the sexual organs of boys and girls. Until now, I have naturally focused my efforts at persuasion on the population of secular parents. After all, it’s quite strange that people without any religious faith anxiously keep track of every heartbeat of their infant in the womb, run with him to the monitor, sonogram and every possible pregnancy test, guard him carefully from the moment of his birth – and then hasten to cut his sexual organ.
The ‘Jewish circumcision,’ however, is performed by a mohel who is not necessarily a doctor, and always without anesthesia. This is an invasive and brutal act – abuse of a helpless infant, which I am certain will be outlawed in the future... According to Jewish law, a Jew is someone born to a Jewish mother and, according to a more progressive approach, anyone who sees himself as belonging to the Jewish people. There were periods and communities in Jewish history in which circumcision was not practiced – from the days of ancient Egypt up to the Communist bloc. Moses was opposed to circumcision and didn’t circumcise his son, and the Children of Israel crossed the Jordan into Canaan uncircumcised.
Circumcision does not determine that a person is Jewish, and non-circumcision does not determine that a person is not Jewish. So to come and claim that the preservation of Jewish identity rises and falls with the cutting of the sexual organs of infants? That this is the most basic symbol that guarantees the survival of Jewish society? That this is the strongest tie connecting the Jewish people to itself and its God? More than faith? More than the Torah and the Ten Commandments? More than the State of Israel and the Land of Israel?
In light of such groundless claims, both religious and nonreligious Jews should start asking themselves questions.”
Uri Misgav, Let’s talk about circumcision. The idea that Judaism is inextricably linked to circumcision must be challenged and corrected. Haaretz (Israel), Jan. 2, 2014.

Israeli intactivists demonstrate in support of Elinor Daniel, after a court coerced her to circumcise her son.

Israeli intactivists demonstrate in support of Elinor Daniel, with a sign that reads "A man's right to control his own body."


Now yoou have tto join your Mobile Machine onn which you plazy Swamp Attack hackwith USB
to your Laptop!

My web-site swamp Attack hack Tool download

After study a few of the blog posts on your website now,
and I really like your way of operating a blog. I bookmarked it to my
bookmark website list and will be checking back soon. Pls take
a look at my web site too and tell me your opinion.

My web site :: carpet cleaning boston ma (

A professional group who have coded a range of hack instruments for A number of the most popular video games.

Here is my webpage: Hungry Shark Evolution Hack Tool Download Free

Additionally yoou may activate the Protection Script on Swamp Attack
hack Hack, and the Proxsy ON option on Swamp Attack hack Hack
too be Comploetely Safe!

Feel free to surf to my website swamp attack ack tool for android (Pauline)

CSR Classics is easy to pay but very difficult because it requires timing plus concentration tto win against the
perfect racers.

My webpage ... csr classics hafk tool android no
survey (Jeffery)

Our device is made for our nice followers so you possibly can easily get Gems and beat your folks with this
great Geem generator.

Have a look aat my site :: growtopia hacks 2015

Step 5. After doing the proper steps, you will have accomplished the Free obtain course of.

Here is my web-site ::

Thanks for your really good information. They are so helpful.

My webpage ... Exposed Skin Care

It's truly very complex in this full of activity life to listen news on TV, thus I simply use internet for that purpose, and obtain the
latest news.

My site הסרת תוצאות חיפוש

I don't even know how I ended up here, but I thought this post was good.
I do not know who you are but certainly you're going to a famous blogger if
you are not already ;) Cheers!

Have a look at my weblog ... website (Hershel)

social Network advertising Rates media can be a
totally new media, however it is still a similar basic table manners which our parents taught.
If you truly need to differentiate yourself from most of marketers which can be using myspace and facebook marketing the wrong
method then its vital that you talk with people and turn personable.
Facebook assists in synchronized participation in events
and conversations.

That's the reason we worked laborious and managed to create this new and iimproved model of Call of Duty Heroes apk

Here is my homepage: call of duty heroes Hacck
tool -,

With FIFA 15 Cons Generator, you can generate limitless cash
and factors toyally free.

My web site fifa 15 ultimate team hack

So that you can start producing the cash, the players have
to first obtain tthe Pixel Gun 3D coin crack software.

My web-site; pixel gun 3d hack ios no survey (

Hi, I do believe this is a great blog. I stumbledupon it ;)
I will return once again since i have bookmarked
it. Money and freedom is the greatest way to change, may you
be rich and continue to guide others.

Feel free to surf to my web-site; אישורי הגעה לחתונה מחיר

Howdy would you mind letting me know which hosting company you're using?
I've loaded your blog in 3 different internet browsers and I must say this blog loads a
lot quicker then most. Can you suggest a good internet hosting provider at a honest price?
Kudos, I appreciate it!

My page: homepage - Kali -

Good post. I learn something totally new and challenging on websites
I stumbleupon on a daily basis. It's always helpful to read
through articles from other authors and use something from their sites.

Also visit my site :: austin migraine cures

I do believe this really is among the most significant information for
me personally. And i am just glad reading your article.
But wish to remark on some general things, The website style is
wonderful, the articles is very great : D. Good job, cheers

Also visit my web blog; ArleenMKolda

Bets to Win pay highest.

Also visit my homepage; m88

Its not my very first time to pay a visit this site, i am just browsing this website dailly and obtain pleasant facts
from this point daily.

Have a look at my homepage :: ChangELamora

Very nice post. I really came across your blog and wished to mention that I've really enjoyed surfing around your blog site
posts. Regardless I'll be subscribing to your feed and I hope
you write again soon!

Look at my web blog ... ScottieWTigg

Hi i just been to your site for the first time and i really loved it, i bookmarked
it and will return.

Feel free to surf to my weblog: dermefface fx7

You possibly can develop yourself within the gake that contains hundreds of ranges or You'll
be able to be part oof the wars in your native space or online.

Visot my blog post :: pixel gun 3d hack ipad Mini

Name it nonetheless you want but trut is, that you simply would like to have
some extra money andd gold in your Pixel Gun 3D

My site: pixel ggun 3d hack cydia,,

Each has viewed comments and discussion do with the other and not instantly to each other.

If you truly would like to differentiate yourself from almost all of marketers which might be using New Social Network Apps networking marketing
the wrong method then its crucial that you connect to people and grow personable.
Choosing Social Network Marketing Over Web Advertising.

It all depends on the type of motor you are trying
to cool and how much heat is being generated inside of it.

In addition, you might need to have an electronic key replaced and a locksmith can also perform this service.

Keep away from any company which has a huge amounts of problems.

Feel free to surf to my site ... מסגריה תל אביב

I do not even know how I ended up here, but I thought this post
was good. I don't know who you are but definitely you're going to a
famous blogger if you are not already ;) Cheers!

Feel free to surf to my homepage; website (Connor)

We desire a different perception to determine why you have our stuckness.

Using your baby bottle brush, scrub inside of the feeder after which
rinse them thoroughly before refilling them. Nevertheless, it
is really an excellent name hummingbird accessories for bathroom this kind of incredible little bird, now don't you think.

netflix member sign in 1994 Sony
and Philips jointly set to develop the digital video disk (DVD).

If you are the ssame as these people, it is time that
you should also get the hack on your turn.

Here is my web-site subway surfers hack iphone download (

With all it's new features, Subway Surfers fever iis oce again off, specially
when Kiloo rolled out an old update and disappointed the gamers.

my web-site subway surfers hack apk 2015;,

When thhe Hack is connected lastly together with your Swamp Attack hackClient you'll be able to set thee quantity of Cooins and
Potions which yyou want to get!

Also visit my webpage :: Swamp attack hacked Apk